Hello to All,
This is a very difficult message to write, and I know that many of you have
somehow come
to believe such accusations and rumors about me that you may not even care to
read what I
write. Nevertheless, it is my duty to write, and I will. This message is from
the Board.
I am truly sad to say that after a full day of discussion and guts-out
"negotiation," Dr. Meredith has separated himself from the Global
Church of God,
and as a consequence the Board had no choice but to terminate his employment
with the
Church.
In spite of the rancor apparent in the letter Dr. Meredith mailed to all
members on
Monday, today's meeting ended amicably, with handshakes and hugs. We bear Dr.
Meredith no
ill will, and told him we would continue to pray for him. He hoped we could
have friendly
contact in the future.
We, the remaining Board members, must respectfully but categorically deny the
long list of
charges and accusations contained in Dr. Meredith's letter. We consider the
letter
extremely libelous. Particularly alarming is the fact that Dr. Meredith
revealed in his
letter that he was already setting up
a competing corporation and that he was asking members to send all their
tithes and
offerings to his personal address, while still in the employ of Global and
drawing his
paycheck from Global. In addition, we consider this to be a breach of his
fiduciary duties
as an officer of the corporation.
It should also be understood by all that the aforementioned letter was written
and mailed
during an interim period in our discussions, which we had agreed to so we
could all pray
about these decisions. Let me amplify that. We held 8 hours of Board meetings
on last
Thursday and Friday without reaching a successful reconciliation. Both
"sides"
had proposed certain actions and neither was able to bend enough to solve the
conflict.
Dr. Meredith had posed the possibility that he would "leave Global,"
which he
had also mentioned during our recent Council meeting.
We recessed the meeting until Tuesday, at Dr. Meredith's request, so that he
could have
time to pray about it. We asked him directly if he would "try to stir up
the Church
this weekend." He said "No, I won't do anything this weekend."
Nevertheless, during the weekend we heard that he made many phone calls to
field ministers
asking for ministers to "stand with him."
Then, late Monday afternoon, in what could have only been miraculous
intervention, we
learned that more than a quarter of a million dollars had suddenly been
drained from
Global's bank account, through the use of unauthorized checks, signed by Dr.
Meredith and
another individual who had
no power to sign any checks. Further, one six-figure check was payable to the
very person
who signed it without authority. Thankfully, this miraculous intervention
allowed us to
stop payment of those unauthorized checks. But we learned that fully one half
million
dollars was moved from our investment account to the operating account to
cover the
checks. The only conclusion we can draw from this even larger unauthorized
transfer of
funds is that even more unauthorized checks were planned to be written later.
A logical
conclusion considering that all of this was done in secrecy!
By the way, these actions were justified by saying that the money was being
used to pay
back loans to individuals. Maybe so, but that process always involves
authorization and is
done according to strict agreements and payback schedules agreed to by all
parties. In
this case, the loans were not due and payable, and the checks were hand-
written,
apparently outside office hours, and not through the person who is responsible
for such
checks. The immediate effect would have been to put the Global Church of God
in financial
jeopardy and on the verge of bankruptcy. When pointed out that this action, in
our
opinion, might potentially constitute criminal activity, Dr. Meredith
suggested that we
could just tell the bank that the signer was a 68-year-old man who didn't
quite know what
he was doing. Incredible!
Meanwhile, rumors of a letter being mailed from outside the office gave us
reason to be
suspicious of the "prayer" interval.
By Tuesday morning, several of us, including Dr. Meredith, had received phone
calls from
concerned ministers and others, pleading with us to do everything possible to
avoid a
"split." We all agreed that this was urgent and important and went
into the
meeting with that in mind. Dr. Meredith
mentioned it right up front, but had concluded that a recommended "third-
party"
consultant would not understand our problems and that our relationship had
deteriorated
too far for this to be practical. Generally speaking, all agreed, though all
parties still
wanted to reach a settlement.
Shortly after the meeting began, Dr. Meredith produced copies of his 4-page
letter and
told us that he had had it mailed to the members on Monday. This was, of
course, not only
contrary to rules regarding the use of the mailing list, but was also done
during the
previously agreed upon "prayer period."
Reading the letter in the meeting, we were appalled at the distortion of
facts, imaginary
incidents, and the invective with which they were presented. All four
additional men on
the Board had been accused of everything from rebellion to conspiracy, and
even a
cancerous attitude.
We all stated our sincere desire to come to an amicable solution to our
problems. But Dr.
Meredith's opening suggestion was that we resign, receive generous severance
and/or
retirement, and go wherever we wanted to.
After meeting from 10:00 am til 2:30 pm, we took a two hour break and
reconvened. We
insisted that since the well had been poisoned so badly by the unauthorized
letter to all
members, there would be no way to go forward unless Dr. Meredith would recant
what he had
written and acknowledge that it was a terribly divisive act to send the letter
out.
Eventually, after much
discussion, he went so far as to say that he would be willing to write a
letter that would
mollify what he had said. Nevertheless, Dr. Meredith would not retract the
basic, libelous
content of the letter.
We asked if he still felt that he would have to leave. He said yes. We then
told him that
we had to consider his actions over the last few days and the content of the
letter as a
decision already made by him to leave this organization. Therefore, to fulfill
our
ministerial and Board responsibilities, we had no choice but to formalize the
dismissal of
Dr. Meredith.
As stated earlier, the meeting ended on a friendly note.
We are fully aware that this tragic situation will make life difficult for you
as well as
us. We can only ask that you carefully and prayerfully seek God's will. We
hope you will
choose to get the facts and make a right judgment about how you will serve
God's people at
this time.
We intend to call a ministerial conference of all full-time men within the
next few weeks
to clear the air on all these accusations and to rebuild the infrastructure of
the Church
so that we might go forward. It is the full intent of those of us here in San
Diego to
continue to do the Work of God as
He opens doors for us.
We are prepared to work with any of you to sort out concerns about meeting
halls, fleet
cars and other matters of mutual interest. We do not have any desire to be
antagonistic or
unreasonable. If the new corporation is interested in purchasing some of our
assets, we
will certainly consider the
request. Meeting hall needs will differ according to what the brethren do and
we will
communicate about that.
Since both your personal situation and ours will depend on what decision you
make, please
let us know what your intentions are as soon as you are sure. If you're sure
now, please
say so, as we need your help to minister to those who remain in Global.
We will let you know the conference plans as soon as we get some feedback from
you.
One final thought: Please remember the hurts and offenses that occurred among
us when we
left WCG and when UCG started, etc. Many people said and did things they now
regret. Why
don't we try to avoid such pitfalls this time around?
If I do not see you in the near future, I hope we will meet again at a better
time. I
appreciate your work and service among God's people. And I consider you
friends. Our
prayers are with you all.
I will be away for Thanksgiving weekend, but can be reached via mobile phone
(619-840-8804). Edwin will also be out of town for the holiday weekend.
Raymond and
Norbert, however, will be available at the office or at home during this
time.
Larry (also writing for: Raymond McNair, Edwin Pope, Norbert Link)
The rest of this message was drafted last night, and may be partially
irrelevant in light
of today's events. Nevertheless, you should read it as background.
[While writing this message, I have heard that some ministers are planning to
hold Bible
Studies or DELS meetings during the week to discuss the situation at HQ and
"make
decisions on what we will do." If that is the case, perhaps this
information should
be added to the mix to allow you to
make a sound and right "decision" based on more facts and with God's
guidance
and blessing.]
In spite of the overwhelming number of rumors circulating in the Church, I
have labored
over how to bring you into the picture without undermining your ability to do
your job of
serving the brethren. Yet, I also understand from experience that you cannot
do your job
if you do not have adequate
information to answer the questions you are asked. You get blindsided and
could be caught
in a situation where any answer you give may prove to be wrong when all the
garbage
clears.
That said, and having talked at length to a couple of pastors in the field
about what the
concerns are, I am now going to attempt to bring you up to date as much as
possible. I am
also quite aware that you alone will have to decide whether to take it or
leave it.
I will mention at this point though, that we have as yet sent no mass
communication to the
membership about any of these problems. We will leave it to your discretion as
shepherds
as to how much of this message you choose to share at this time with the flock
in your
care. We do plan, however, to send out an official communication to our
members in the
near future.
What Dr. Meredith perceives as a power struggle probably began during the
November '97
Council of Elders meeting, and really heated up during the February meeting,
when we
unanimously confirmed that we would practice government by consensus of the
Council. It
broke into the open during the latest Council meeting a couple of weeks ago,
when Dr.
Meredith made it abundantly clear that he had no intention of abiding by the
unanimous
agreements of the Council of Elders and the Board of Directors concerning the
subject of
"Church government," which had been discussed for endless hours over
the last 5
meetings.
During and after this most recent Council meeting, Dr. Meredith repeated his
previous
threat that he might have to "pull a David Hulme." He has since told
us in no
uncertain terms that he will have to make a decision of whether to leave
Global.
Yes, the real issue IS Church government!! But, even more than that, it is the
integrity
of the Church, the ministry, the Council, the Board, and our doctrinal
positions and
processes that are at stake here. There are many and varied reasons why the
Board has
recently had to take a stand on
principle, and they had nothing whatever to do with "taking
over."
Volumes could be written about our discussions and the various writings,
sermons, and
actions that have flowed from them. Because how we all do our jobs and operate
every day
is a function of Church government. And this whole "debate"
originated with Dr.
Meredith's booklet, "When Should You Follow Church Government?" Many
of the
ministers and members who came to
Global in the early years had read and accepted the statements made in that
booklet. In
fact, it was WHY many came to Global at that time!
Our bylaws, the Council, the Board, and our Articles of Incorporation as a
non-profit,
tax-exempt organization were all based on the concepts and teachings contained
in that
booklet and in sermons and conversations about this subject. Personally, I had
several
such conversations with Dr. Meredith at the time I was deciding whether to
come to Global.
I expect that some of you had similar conversations and concerns.
Even when the subject was thoroughly reviewed by the Council in February, Dr.
Meredith
added his voice to the unanimous decision to continue to preach and proclaim
that form of
government, based on "multitude of counsel." This governmental
structure also
contained a system of checks and balances to prevent one person from leading
the Church
off course, with provision to correct doctrinal, administrative or personal
problems.
Amazingly, even after sending a letter to the entire membership confirming
this structure,
on June 11, 1998, Dr. Meredith continued to contradict the decisions of the
Council of
Elders, both in private conversations and in sermons and in meetings.
Additionally, he has
said several times, including in the initial Council meeting on the subject,
something
like this: "Well, I wrote the booklet on government to help people come
out of WCG,
but I never believed it was the way the Church should be governed."
What??
In fact, when Mr. Raymond McNair recently asked Dr. Meredith whether he
believed God had
guided the Council, after we had opened the meetings with prayer and fervently
requested
God's inspiration and blessing, the reply shocked us all. He said, "Well
those are
just words. Don't you think the Catholics pray before their meetings?"
I use these examples only to give you the tiniest bit of flavor of what we
have been
dealing with for some time. We did not share these things with you because we
honestly
believed they could be worked out and that Dr.Meredith would come to see where
he was
wrong.
A lot of our members, and perhaps a lot of you, don't care much about
government
structure. However, the more obvious spiritual problem we are dealing with
arises out of
this conflict. The way Dr. Meredith began to deal with this issue was to say
that some of
the men at headquarters were trying to tie his hands, and take over the
Church. These
"accusations" began to surface in the field, and the rumor mill took
over.
Frankly, it was some time before those of us on the Board knew where they were
originating. Nevertheless, a lot of discord was sown.
This is ugly and I know it, but I must put this in a little more context for
you.
While most of you don't give a hang about how the Board works, or why, let me
tell you
that it is the focal point of all business and legal liability for the Church.
In
addition, the Board members can in some cases be held individually and
collectively liable
for debts of, or judgments against, the corporation. We are also responsible
to state and
federal governments for the way the Church conducts it's affairs.
The fact that some of you know about this is clear from the immediate call
today for
repayment of large loans some ministers and brethren have made to the Church
during our
financial crisis a couple of years ago. They are being used as leverage to
pressure the
Board to yield to Dr. Meredith's
persistent claim to be in sole authority and make unilateral decisions, while
the Board
bears the liability. This of course could possibly bankrupt the Church, which
would serve
no one's purpose. I have to liken it to a "scorched earth" policy in
battle.
Dr. Meredith has previously threatened that he would, "take it over your
heads to the
lay members of the Church." (Doesn't this sound like democracy?) What is
the Church
saying now? Don't I recall that you were angry with senior ministers in WCG
who never
stood up to repeated wrongdoing, even chiding me personally for not having
done more? And
now am I to understand that the ministry and members are saying, "We are
comfortable
and happy. Tell us smooth things"?
Men who believe they have a duty to God and His people to stand up for the
Truth cannot do
that. There is much more detail and many different aspects to the current
situation, but I
see no need to cover it now.
Fellow ministers and brethren, we are in a collossal crisis in the Church. But
it is the
Church of God. Christ is the Head, and it is to Him that we should look for
deliverance
from this trial.
Having counseled with others here, several members of the Board would like to
ask the
brethren to join us in a fast, to humble ourselves before our Creator and seek
His will,
not our own, in resolving this crisis. Many of you will recall that this is
the approach
Mr. Armstrong took in 1974 when
the Church was in danger of coming apart. He quoted the prophet Joel, saying,
"Sanctify a fast, call a solemn assembly" (1:14). We must not fast
for a
particular outcome, or ask God to do what WE want, but rather that He will
help us to see
clearly and understand His will.
Let us as members of the Body of Christ set aside the Sabbath of December 5,
1998, to fast
together and draw close to God. Let us beseech God for His mercy and favor,
and that He
will reveal His perfect will to us.
It is our hope that those of you receiving this message will announce this
fast to the
brethren, regardless of your present personal "understanding" of
this whole
matter.
I am grieving over having to write this, especially since I am well aware that
I have been
made out to be one of the evil people. But such is life. I will greatly
appreciate your
prayers, because praying is the most valuable thing any of us can do.
Thanks for listening.
Larry